The problem with most CD reviews is you only
get the opinion of the one critic doing the review. So we thought it might
be fun to try something new here by giving the exact same CD to two different
critics (or more) and see what they each come up with and just how much
difference a single critic's opinion can make.
Note: due to the nature of this series, the reviews
may tend to be more in the first person than you are used to with music
criticism.
10 Years - The
Autumn Effect
Label:Republic Records
Dan Upton's review he gave it a rating
of
I was first attracted to 10 Years by the
fact that they were tapped as support on tour with Disturbed and Ill Nino.
Take that and add to it that they've opened for Velvet Revolver, and that
The Autumn Effect's producer has also worked with Staind and Velvet
Revolver, and you can get a pretty good idea of what to expect: radio-friendly
modern hard rock. This means they're easy to write off after a first listen;
that's a shame, because they have more to offer than a lot of the current
crop of radio fare.
In the band's bio, frontman Jesse Hasek
says music should be about feeling and intensity, and that as a band they
want people to think and feel emotions again. Lyrically and vocally, they
achieve this: the vocals, while clean throughout, are expressive and cover
a wide range from introspective and quiet, sounding like he's talking to
himself, to passionate yells and wails. It's refreshing to me to hear a
modern rock vocalist who can express power without resorting growls and
screams. Lyrically the CD speaks of emotions, experiences with people,
and the state of society, from "Empires" criticism of materialism to the
lamenting of people isolating themselves in "Seasons to Cycle."
Musically, on the other hand, they don't
quite reach their goal of feeling and intensity. A lot of the music is
standard modern rock fare, intros and choruses with one guitar riffing
away and the other playing a higher melodic part, verses carried by the
bass with some picked melodic lines, and the occasional chunky breakdown.
Not every song follows that pattern, but most do. The tight production
also takes away some of the intensity--not that you have to be sloppy and
distorted to be intense, but it's still possible to be too smooth.
Where 10 Years really shine musically though
is in the long instrumental passages in songs such as "Through the Iris"
and the title track. These aren't prog rock crazy solo breaks, but they
do show a talent for composing atmosphere. Using some of these chops more
often in the songs could've brought them further above the pack.
It's too bad 10 Years can be written off
as just another band in the heap, because there are some strong tracks
and some musical sensibilities and talent that won't come through on singles--even
if a song like "Through the Iris" makes it to radio, the quest for a 3
minute rock song will probably lead to its instrumental passage being cut.
All the same, if you like all things modern rock, this CD is for you.
antiGUY's review he gave it a rating
of
I'm always a bit leery of bands you hear
a lot about before they even release an album. Remember Sinnistar? On the
other hand, I'm always interested to hear the actual music that creates
such a buzz to see if it lives up to expectations.
I really didn't know what to expect with
10 Years. I've been seeing their name mentioned on numerous hard rock sites
for the past few months and had never heard them. Then I discovered the
buzz about that came more from winning fans over opening for bands like
Static-X and Velvet Revolver than the typical hype machine. So, when I
saw that we had received the CD in for review I immediately wanted to check
it out only to find out Dan had beaten me to it. Lucky the gods smiled
on me as a couple days later Universal sent another copy and the boss handed
it off to yours truly.
Now we get to the acid test. What was all
the hoopla about and do these guys measure up to it? After one listen,
I understood the buzz about the band. 10 Years offers up something different
yet familiar and the obvious evolution of alternative metal by mixing the
best aspects of numetal with Tool like dynamics.
I know people hate comparisons but I just
can't get away from the progressive Tool/APC aspects to 10 Years and that
is easily their biggest strength, but when coupled with their ability to
write hooks and you have a major contender on your hands.
10 Years also accomplishes what many bands
aspire to achieve but very few fail in the execution; and that is finding
a balance. Especially when dealing with progressive based bands, some tend
to go off the deep end and forsake mass appeal but 10 Years manage to capture
an unquestionable progressive nature to their music while still offering
something that could easily land a lot of radio airplay. However, in the
end, this band does have real musical credibility while having mainstream
viability; really the best of both worlds. While 10 Years may turn off
the hardest of the hardcore metal fans, they should find a rather large
audience for this impressive debut, because it really does live up to the
hype.
Listen to the entire album
Listen
with Windoz Media - Listen
with Real Audio
Preview
and Purchase This CD Online
Visit
the official homepage
More
articles for this artist
tell
a friend about this review
.
|