The problem with most CD reviews is you only
get the opinion of the one critic doing the review. So we thought it might
be fun to try something new here by giving the exact same CD to two different
critics (or more) and see what they each come up with and just how much
difference a single critic's opinion can make.
Note: due to the nature of this series, the reviews
may tend to be more in the first person than you are used to with music
criticism.
Rammstein
- Reise Reise
Label: Universal
Records
DeadSun's review - he gave it a rating
of
Staunch. Vigorous. Unique. Bombastic.
There are plenty of words to describe the
music that German industrial metal act Rammstein has been putting out since
their 1995 debut release, “Herzeleid”.
While the rhythmic dimensions that the
bass, six-strings, and drums deliver to the music can be argued for, or
against, as monolithic and mechanical, with Rammstein it always boils down
to the accents and embellishments that they drape across that rock solid
spine of rhythm. The result is often music that conveys strength and weight
but, paradoxically, conveys a noble sentimentality, and memorable melody/harmony
accompaniments.
Which brings us to “Reise, Reise”. This
is not to be rendered as the German noun for “journey”, but rather as a
verb--- “arise”. Evidently, “reise, reise” was a reveille call of sorts,
used by German seamen in days gone by.
The first musical virtue that “Reise, Reise”
summons up is--- unsurprisingly enough for this band--- the precise clarity
and attention to detail that was lavished upon the sound mix. Stefan Glaumann
did a terrific job behind the mixing console. Every note finds its way
into the listener’s ears, doing so in a manner that should placate even
the most discriminating audiophile.
The recording opens with the title track,
and Rammstein wastes no time in laying down what is patently their strong
suit. “Reise, Reise” resounds with a swaying, epic sound--- and a warm,
patently hymnal chorus that beckons the audience to join in and be a part
of. Make no mistake… that is the formulaic bread and butter of this band…
and they excel at it.
This recording arguably has seven or eight
potential singles on it, which lends a qualified testimony as to just how
solid the song writing is. “Mein Teil” (translated: “My Part”) is a forceful
and creepy musical crusher about Armin Meiwes, a German man who found a
victim, online, who was willing to be killed, and then eaten by Meiwes.
Hors d’ouevres, anyone? With “Dalai Lama”, longtime Rammstein fans will
be comforted by a mood that beckons back to some of the material that was
laid out on 1997’s “Sehnsucht”. Till Lindemann takes some interesting turns
with his vocal delivery, proving that while identity is an ever-important
ingredient to Rammstein’s ethos, their approach is not a static one. While
every new album picks up where the last left off, each has a few dashes
of something new added to it. “Keine Lust” and “Los”--- the former
played in a hard-bouncing swing time, and the later with its clean, rhythmic
guitar and throbbing bass walks--- yield up a fresh avenue for Rammstein,
and to me play a vital role in giving “Reise, Reise” an identity of it’s
own. With “Amerika”, we find what is probably the most commercially accessible
song off of the album--- a sarcastically blithe casting of contemporary
America from a perspective commonly shared by many of our European cousins.
Que serra, serra.
The verdict: “Reise, Reise” delivers the
heavy goods--- massive in its sound, and awash with melody and ambience.
I was, more than ¾ of the way through the first listening, poised
to give it an 85.
… that was, of course, before I had heard
the tenth song on the album.
“Onne Dich” is simply gorgeous--- both
powerful and frail, sharp with overwhelming poignancy, and singularly beautiful
when vocalized in the German tongue. Here lies the dramatic centerpiece
on “Reise, Reise”. This is the kind of song that is vital to a band like
Rammstein, who hangs so much importance on connecting with their audience…
especially during a live performance.
Solely on the basis of “Onne Dich”, I bump
this album up to a 90. My hope is that others will share in my sentiment.
DS
Brad Podray's Review - He gave it a
Rating of
Well, those wacky
Germans are at it again. No, they are not marching troops through
Belgium. What I mean is there is now another release from Germany’s
most successful group to invade U.S. soil…musically, that is. “Reise
Reise,” is an album right up the alley that we’ve come to love Rammstein
for. Infused with gnashing guitars, ambient keys, and vocals that
sound deliriously angry regardless of the subject matter, this album easily
stacks up to its predecessors.
The vocals throughout
the album are entirely German, with the exception of a few choice phrases
in the track “Amerika” where this writer can only extrapolate that they
are choosing to satire the way we live over here in the states(Featuring
English sung lyrics: “We’re all living in Amerika, Coca Cola, Wonderbra.”)
Mickey Mouse and Santa Claus are also mentioned in some sort of context
I didn’t get, as my ability to comprehend German is non-existent.
The best single word
to describe this album in relation to Rammstein’s other work is that it’s
more “Majestic.” Yeah, it’s a pretentious-as-hell word to use, but
just check out the title track “Reise Reise” and you’ll see what I mean.
The songs seem to hit on a scale that seems more dramatic than the old
smack-you-in-the-face-blitzkrieg Rammstein of Seinsucht. The pace
of the tracks is slightly slower than what we’re used to and orchestral
strings saturate a great deal of the soundscape.
Track 2, “Mein Teil”,
definitely doesn’t screw around, showing off Rammstein’s great ability
to craft modern day war anthems(note: For all I know, he’s singing about
how much he loves ice cream in the summer time…I don’t know. All
I know is that it sounds like a damn war song).
The song that probably
sticks out the most amongst the tracks is track 7, “Moskau.” In this
track, the band chugs along, showing off all the things Rammstein does
well, but this time they also feature the introduction of some totally
rocking Russian female vocals. The tracks, while all original enough
not to be confused with each other, can easily be given the same generalized
sound description: hard beat, dramatically belted out German vocals, and
ultra-catchy rock guitar/basslines, not to mention enough synthesis to
keep electronic music fans at least slightly interested.
The final track,
“Amour” should also not be missed if you’ve been waiting for that dramatic
soundtrack to your last days together with that German girl you hooked
up with whilst studying abroad. This song wasn’t going to receive
its own special sentences after first spin, but now that this reviewer
has heard it a second time, it’s going to take a wrecking ball to get it
out of his head.
Closing statement:
It’s Rammstein on a little less methamphetamine than you’re used to, but
it’s still damn good.
Listen
to samples and Purchase this CD online
|